Self-employment has become fashionable among young Indian workers as they seek wage employment in the gig economy. These include mandatory email verification, one-way video interviews, etc along with strict control on commissions and wages, Ola, Uber, Swiggy, Zomato, and Urban Company, among others depend on gig-workers to operate. While these platforms offer new possibilities for the gig workers themselves, they also bring issues concerning these workers’ rights and regulations since many of them are not considered employees at all but independent contractors. Indian law, which has generally protected employees in conventional workplaces, offers difficulties with this categorization.
The Gig Economy in India: An Overview
A critical segment of the gig economy consists of nontraditional or often contract-based work that is often conforming to the employment of clients or customers Mostly, gig economy jobs entail contracting with clients through an application interface. While gig work acts as a source of daily income, the flexibility of not being confined to the usual 9-5 job, and another source of income, gig work does not come with the security that is attached to full-time employment. The gig worker is referred to as an independent contractor which entails that he or she does not enjoy the same legal rights and privileges as those offered to full-time employees. Such protections and benefits are as follows minimum wage, paid leave, social security, and many more.
A look at the legal challenges faced by gig workers
1. Ambiguity in Legal Definitions: Indian labour law does not want gig workers to be clearly defined. They consider GIG workers as having vanity jobs which creates loopholes exposing them to lacking formal employee rights. At the moment, there is no mechanism for distinguishing between an employee and a contractor, and hence workers’ rights such as a minimum wage, protection in working conditions, and right to unionization are non-existent.
2. Issues related to classification: Regarding the decision-making of gig workers as independent contractors there are several problems. Platforms also behave in a fashion similar to traditional employers, regulating their workers’ work schedules, wages, and rates of performance. The main case here includes the Uber drivers’ employment status; this was in the UK Supreme Court in the case of Uber BV vs Aslam, the court found that Uber drivers require minimum wage and holidays among other basic employment rights. Thus, there has been much debate in India about deciding gig engagers as employees.
3. There are social security issues: gig workers, for instance, they are not privileged to the social security status of employees like health insurance, pension, and unemployment among others. Some of these issues will be addressed under ‘Code on Social Security, 2020’, wherein the gig and platform workers shall be covered. There is a proposed social security fund for these workers that is quite pro-working on the process. Thus, despite the relative novelty of implementation, it is apparent that an array of gig workers remains under-protected.
4. Issues of Fair Wages and Working Conditions: Several gig workers state that they make less than minimum wage and that they dedicate several hours to ensuring that they make ends meet. Right now, no governing body is involved in guaranteeing that gig workers are being paid a reasonable wage or that they aren’t employed in environments that could be dangerous. One must not forget that the gig economy in India is highly volatile given recent strikes by delivery workers of platforms like Zomato and Swiggy.
Precedents of Importance
1. The Ola and Uber drivers petition in Delhi (2017): In 2017 drivers associated with Ola and Uber companies attempted to legally challenge their contractor status and become official employees by presenting a petition to the Delhi High Court. The case additionally highlighted the need for legal changes for gig workers, even though the latter are no instances of employees under the law of Australia. This is done by giving them a minimum wage, work hours, and social security provisions.
2. Zomato and Swiggy workers' protests: Some bike delivery contractors in the food delivery platforms like Zomato and Swiggy have previously complained of low emoluments, unhygienic working environment, and no health insurance among others. Although these protests have helped shake up the plight of the gig workers, there has been no shift in laws governing gig workers.
3. Global Influence – Uber BV vs. Aslam (UK Supreme Court, 2021): While this is not an Indian case, the UK Supreme Court held that Uber drivers are workers capable of claiming workers’ rights. This has recently raised a discussion in India as to whether gig workers should be redrawn and protected under the laws in the same manner as employees.
Reform of regulations and more on the path ahead
The Indian government has passed the Code on Social Security, 2020 in its attempts to protect the rights of gig workers and grant some form of protection to platform and gig workers as well. However, it is still needed to establish wide and special legislation for the gig economy, which will clear the definitions, set fair working wages, and improve the conditions of access to social security.
Conclusion
That is why the growth of the gig economy in India became the only way for millions of people to have freedom and some income, but at the same time, they face many risks and violations, as the gig economy is not regulated by law. Therefore, to ensure reasonable protection and fair treatment of gig workers in India, the laws and regulations of India need to be established by learning from the global laws and regulations and then implementing them according to the Indian condition. On the ends of the staff, there will be more effective workforce equity, and on the broader economy, there will be more effective economic sustainability.
To ensure the blog on the legal dimensions of the gig economy in India is well-supported by reliable data, you can refer to the following sources:
Indian Government Reports:
Code on Social Security, 2020: Provides information on the inclusion of gig and platform workers under India's social security laws.
Ministry of Labour and Employment - Offers updates on labour codes and regulations relevant to gig and platform workers.
Judicial Cases and Legal Databases:
Ola and Uber Drivers' Petition in Delhi (2017): This case can be referenced from legal databases such as Manupatra or SCC Online.
Uber BV vs. Aslam (UK Supreme Court, 2021): The details and implications of this landmark ruling are available on the UK Supreme Court's official website or through comprehensive legal analysis in Lexology.
News Articles and Industry Reports:
Worker Protests and Conditions: Articles from trusted news sources like The Hindu, Economic Times, or BBC News cover protests by gig workers at Zomato, Swiggy, and others, highlighting their demands for better pay and working conditions.
Impact of Gig Economy: Reports by industry bodies like NITI Aayog or research by Oxfam India often explore the broader impact of the gig economy on the Indian workforce.
https://www.niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2022-06/25th_June_Final_Report_27062022.pdf
Research Papers and Academic Journals:
Research papers on the gig economy’s legal framework can be found in journals like the Indian Journal of Labour Economics or articles from academic institutions that explore labor laws in India.
International Influences and Comparisons:
Comparisons with global cases, such as the UK Supreme Court ruling on Uber drivers, can be referenced from international law reviews and platforms like The Guardian, and Financial Times, or legal analyses on platforms like Law360.
LINKS-